Thesis Proposal

 Last Updated: 09/09/23


Thesis Abstract / Thesis Statement


[Insert title here] will explore the sentiments of speculative dreams for the future. Research pertaining to this thesis will include the communication between speculative fiction and shifts of cultural norms along with how speculative fiction has been explored over the past twenty years (literature, film, and art). Furthermore, observing how these fictions have affected every day / slice of life speculation during the COVID pandemic. With this background in mind, how have these cultural speculations altered my personal imaginings of my life to come? The culmination of these personal speculations of my future will be displayed as vignette/diorama scenes. These scenes will merge possible outcomes that I’ve imagined for myself in kinetic sculptures. 

(if you have any ideas for titles, I'm all ears (would be fun to depict that phrase))


Thesis Corner



Thesis Corner is a physical Corner in my studio space. It is curated set of inspiration images, sketches, and  notes. 



Thesis Corner Inspiration Images


Jane Haselden

Limpet Basket (in progress)

2022


The Garden of Earthly Delights
Hieronymus Bosch
Oil Paint on Panel
1490-1510

Lizzy O'Donnell
Painting 
2022

Vanessa Bowman
The Vegetable Garden
Oil Pint

"Animated Life" Portland Art Museum
Coraline Garden Set (2009)
2017

Erik H Gellert 
Stuffed 
Ceramic & acrylic paint

Gwen Van Knippenburg
Baking
Illustration
2022

Jenni Pasanen
Mask Obscura 
Digital Painting & AI
2022


Thesis Corner Sketches


General Structure:
Legs made of balusters (the pins of stair railings) with the diorama built on top of the base table


Sketch of the death vignette

Zoomed out sketches of the death vignette. With death's inevitability, keep the movement relatively still beyond maybe making the trees "move in the breeze"



An example of a shift of forms in the dioramas, anything from furniture, to nature, to buildings will reflect the variations of outcomes possible in the future


Thesis Proposal 

A Cup of Tea in Infinite Futures: A Positive Look at Speculative Fates



A proposal submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for

the Degree of Master of Fine Arts in Art.


Isabel Kelly


Supervisor: Annie Martin

Fine Arts: Art

June 26th, 2023



2 


Abstract


“A Cup of Tea in Infinite Futures: A Positive Look at Speculative Fates,” will explore the

sentiments of speculation for the future. Research pertaining to this thesis includes communication

between speculative fiction and shifts of cultural norms along with how speculative fiction has been

explored over the past twenty years (literature, film, art, and social media). Furthermore, there are

observations on how these fictions have affected every day / slice-of-life speculation during the

COVID-19 pandemic. With this background in mind, how have these cultural speculations altered

personal imaginings of life to come? The culmination of these personal speculations of the future

will be displayed as vignette/diorama scenes. These scenes will merge possible outcomes that I’ve

imagined for myself as kinetic sculptures.


Key Words: Speculation, Future, Slice-of-Life, Cottagecore, Automata




Introduction



        Speculation has been experienced throughout human history, appearing in many ways. In

Speculative Everything (Dunne & Raby, 2013), the act of speculation is the act of imagining various

outcomes, scenarios, and worlds. The act of speculating is found in a variety of forms, from the

quantifiably predicted instances of tomorrow’s weather, to theorizing the state of the world based

on patterns from the past, to what you may eat for dinner tomorrow, to asking questions, “What

if…?” The aim of this thesis is to research the less measurable forms of speculation, the sentiments

towards speculative futures, and their effects within personal life.

        

        In the Research Aims, I will discuss the background of contemporary speculative fiction

(stories that are depicted in worlds unlike our own) in forms such as literature, film, art, etc.

Dystopian fiction was one of the primary forms of speculative fiction during the first two decades of

the twenty first century, especially in young adult fiction which many later millennial and early

generation Z children (children born 1990-2000), including myself, grew up consuming. However,

in the years since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic (2020 to today), there has been a shift in

interest from dystopian into slice-of-life fiction. A more mundane form of speculative fiction

focusing on daily life and communication while still taking place in realms different/outside of our

own. One specific form of slice-of-life, cottagecore, has spread outside of fantastical yet mondain

speculation and into everyday life.


        In the Methodology section, there is first a discussion of my inner quandaries and

contextualization of the information provided in Research Aims. How have the ideas and

speculative trends shifted my understanding of personal future speculations? Personal speculations

take a mundane form, such as what will I eat for dinner tomorrow, but can also encompass more

arching questions pertaining to the future. What do you want to be when you grow up, where

would you want to live, etc.? Over the years, I have looked towards the future and have had various

dreams of what may lay ahead, many thoughts of which are affected by forms of slice-of-life

speculative fiction. Along with the inner quandaries, object implementation of the project portion of

this thesis will be communicated. Object implementation consists of the initial plans for

constructing the thesis project and the influences on the structure / visuals of the object being

made. These artworks will be the visualization of my personal speculative futures, through threedimensional

kinetic vignettes or automata. Four to five scenes will depict a melding of many of the

possible futures I’ve daydreamed. Influences for the physical form of the project include visuals

associated with cottagecore (nature, crafting, and so on) and explanations between automata’s

mechanical movement imitating shifts of the futures. Finally, the methodology section ends with the

proposed structure of the support paper.



Research Aims



        Speculation is an imaginative exercise, thinking about how the universe, the world, and we

personally could change. A particularly potent form of speculation abundant today is dystopia.

Dystopias are imaginings of worlds experiencing great misfortune and/or injustices. This form of

speculative fiction is not a new phenomenon; however, children growing up in the 2000s and 2010s

found themselves in a saturated market. Dystopian literature rose in popularity during the 20th

century with classics such as: A Brave New World (Huxley, 1932/2006), 1984 (Orwell, 1949/1961),

Fahrenheit 451 (Bradbury, 1953/2012). The late 2000s and 2010s had an explosion of young adult

dystopian fiction including novels such as: Unwind (Shusterman, 2007/2009), The Hunger Games

(Collins, 2008/2010), and Divergent (Roth, 2011/2014). Novels from both the twentieth and

twenty first century were converted into television shows and movies in the 2010s: A Handmaid’s

Tale (Atwood, 1985/2006) with the show adaptation (Barker et al., 2017-present), The Giver

(Lowry, 1993) with the movie based on the novel (Noyce, 2014), and The Hunger Games (Lawrence

& Ross, 2012).


        In recent years, many have been able to imagine these fictional dystopian worlds becoming

our reality. March 2020 was the start of quarantine for the majority of the world as COVID-19

spread. The unknown filled a myriad of people with dread and the inability to visit loved ones as the

number of cases climbed. The closest to a pandemic that children of the 2000s and 2010s had seen

were popularized in zombie media such as the comic books (Kirkman, 2003-2019) and TV show

(Darabont, 2010-2021), The Walking Dead and the popular video game Plague Inc. (Ndemic

Creations, 2012).


        The Doomsday Clock, created by The Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists (1947) displays how

close to humanmade world destruction we are. In January 2023, it had shifted the closest to

midnight (doomsday) that it’s ever been, ninety seconds. According to The Bulletin of the Atomic

Scientists the War in Ukraine is the greatest influence of this fluctuation, “Russia’s war on Ukraine

has raised profound questions about how states interact, eroding norms of international conduct

that underpin successful responses to a variety of global risks” (Mecklin, 2023). The rollback of Roe

v. Wade in the United States allowing for an abundance of new state regulations, constricting to

outright banning and hunting those who wish to seek abortions. While discussing this loss of bodily

autonomy, many have found similarities from this situation to the dystopian fiction, The

Handmaid’s Tale. Even the author, Atwood herself, pointed out the resemblance of The Handmaid’s

Tale and loss of Roe v. Wade in an Instagram post of her holding a mug saying, “I Told You So” after

Roe v. Wade was overturned.


        With the similarities between dystopian fiction and our reality increasing, many have been

retreating into escapist fictions. This trend has been witnessed before during the Great Depression

in the United States. Some escapist movies of the time include two of the most popular films of the

time, Snow White and the Seven Dwarves (Hand et al., 1938) and The Wizard of Oz (Fleming, 1939).

Today, however, there has been a slight shift. The environments and characters may still be

fantastical, but the plots are closer to reality, slice-of-life speculative fiction. There has been a trend

towards slice-of-life speculative fiction, with popularity in books such as: A Monk and Robot

(Chambers, 2021) book series, Before the Coffee Gets Cold (Kawaguchi, 2015) with English

translation (Trousselot, 2020), and Legends and Lattes (Baldree 2022). All these books may have

fantastical elements such as time travel or sentient robots, yet they focus on the relationships

between characters and their everyday lives, displaying moments of mundanity. There are no wars

to be fought, no great world-saving quests, just tea, coffee, and communication.


        Slice-of-life speculative fiction is not only in literature, but also on social media (content on

platforms such as Instagram, Pinterest and TikTok, etc) in the form of art. During the quarantine,

when a significant portion of the population was isolated in their homes, one of the primary forms

of escape were these slice-of-life speculative ideas of “cottagecore.” Cottagecore, on the surface, is

an escapist aesthetic focusing on the fairytale-like imagery of cozy cottages, forests, gardens, and

handicrafts. The sentiment for the aesthetic is nothing new. Edwin Heathcote relates the trend to

Marie Antoinette’s, “faux-rural hamlet” (a group of small buildings too small to be a village) built on

the Palace of Versailles grounds, the Arts and Crafts movement of the late 19th early 20th century,

and the hippies of the 60s and 70s. However, the latest iteration of the trend has been pushed to the

forefront with the help of social media and the COVID-19 pandemic.


        What has been thought of as simple aesthetic living on a digital plane, extended out of our

screens during COVID lockdown. A great amount of the population was stuck at home; thus, there

was time to go beyond the confines of digital mood boards. People started practicing the traditional

skills and crafts associated with the aesthetic: cooking/baking, sewing, knitting, crocheting,

gardening, etc. The inspirational and fantastical skills became available as free time also increased.

As a result of this time, cottagecore turned some of the elements of this slice-of-life speculative

escapism, this quant hopeful lifestyle, into an achievable possibility for many.




Methodology



        We’ve been introduced to speculation early on in our lives. What do you want to be when

you grow up; are you going to go to college; what type of partner would you be with; when are you

going to get married; are you going to have kids; where would you want to live; etc.? Life in our late

teens and twenties is when many of us start making more impactful life decisions for our future.

Thus, many speculative questions arise. For me these were quandaries such as: What am I going to

do after undergraduate school; what if I don’t get into graduate school; what will happen if I need to

move for a school or job; will I be in a relationship; what type of careers do I see myself in; etc.?

Getting an acceptance letter from the University of Lethbridge and an engagement ring on my finger

alleviated some of those initial inquiries, but new questions rose to the surface to take their place.

Therefore, I’ve chosen to embrace future speculation through my MFA thesis research.


        Often, in order to understand the future, we need some context from the past. This can be

true for a look into speculative fiction or reviewing our own lives. Growing up, I was able to see the

effects of the negative national and international shifts made evident by the increased security at

airports after 9/11, active shooter drills became as common place as tornado and fire drills, the

frequency of hateful language and action increased in the US when Trump became president, and so

on. In millennial and generation Z childhoods, we grew up with the warnings of dystopian literature

with saviors and survivors fighting for change. Many of us believe in fighting for change, but at the

same time there have been years and layers of bad news. Progress even regressing in the instances

of Row v. Wade, book burns, and recent bills against freedom of speech being pushed through the

United States.


        With one of the greatest uncertainties being the COVID-19 quarantine, I understood the

desire for a form of positive escapism. Slice-of-life speculative fiction did just that. Media such as

Animal Crossing: New Horizon came out at the perfect time and is a great instance of this

speculative fiction. In the this game, the player is neighbors with a bunch of happy and cute animals,

while also being able to own a home (another questionable prospect for generation Z) and decorate

an island to their heart’s content. They can visit friend’s islands and it was like visiting a friend’s

home when that wasn’t possible in real life at the time. The game provides and illusion of more

control and freedom when compared to the world outside.


        Cottagecore combines the escapism of slice-of-life speculative fiction with our reality.

People took what was thought to be an abstract aesthetic and applied the fantastical lifestyle

elements of cozy self-sufficiency and whimsical stability to their everyday. For me, cottagecore was

something to aspire to in my own future along with a sense of nostalgia. Much of what would be

considered the essence of cottagecore was instilled in me from a young age. I’ve always wanted to

create with my hands whether that be learning to knit, sew, bake, garden, etc. Cottagecore

displayed much of what I have already learned and want to learn in a positive speculative package.

Some of these mentioned key habits and modes of thinking, I will carry into the future.


        To explore my research through visual means, I plan to construct four or five kinetic

vignette/dioramas of personal speculations of my future. Each will be roughly 18 inches in

diameter and 40 inches tall. The bases will be constructed from wood; however, the vignettes

themselves will be mixed media. They will likely include polylactic acid (PLA, type of plastic used in

fused deposition model (FDM) printing), textiles, and paint. Among these dioramas, they will

display merging possible outcomes since nothing in the future is set in stone and different choices

can lead down alternative paths. For example, one of the vignettes will display a garden scene. I

know my partner and I have been intrigued by the idea of having ducks or chickens in a yard, thus

chickens in the garden may morph into ducks and ducks morph into mourning doves since we may

end up in an apartment instead of a house.


        The kinetic element of these sculptures will come in the form of automata. Automata

(automaton singular) are figures that mimic a repeated motion through mechanics. They began as

manual objects, dating back to ancient Greece with their heyday in the 19th century. Some of the

most popular automata of the 1800s were mechanical caged birds. An advanced automaton of that

period is Draughtsman-Writer by Henri Maillardet (1800), which could write and draw a set

number of images and phrases. With time, motors and electrical components were added. Some of

today’s best-known automata can be found in Disney Parks as animatronics. The reason I wish to

include kinetic sculpture in my thesis project is because it is a physical way for my future to shift

and move. Life isn’t stagnant. Why should these representations of possible life be still? The choices

one makes help drive their future forward whether that be to turn the crank, or the influence others

make upon the future. Thus, I’ve decided these possible depictions of my futures should be lifepowered

(audience-powered) instead of mechanically powered. Onlookers are invited to look upon

my positive outlooks and may reflect on their own hopes for the future. The audience also has

influence upon on said futures through the interactions they have with others or in this case, adding

movement with a turn of the crank.


        In preparation for creating the mechanisms required for the automata components, I

dedicated time into learning how automata work during my 2023 Spring Semester Graduate Studio

course. Throughout the semester, I sketched eight designs to contextualize automata mechanics. Six

of the designs were actualized as prototypes, the first four are constructed with from cardboard,

paper, tape, dowels, PLA mechanical components (self-designed and 3D printed), and adhesives.

These four automata helped my general understanding of how the mechanics worked, along with

how said mechanics needed support. There was unwanted shifting in the structure of these

automata, causing the mechanics to veer out of place. To combat instability, I transitioned to a

wooden hull for the mechanical components. As predicted, there was less shifting, and the

movement was repeatable and smooth.


        This thesis project will revolve around my positive speculations for the future using the

methods stated above. Manual automata elements will be included throughout to suggest the

influence that people can have upon their own futures and that of others. I may be constructing this

future for myself by turning the crank, but, outside influence can still occur, effecting the movement

of the future.


        As for the structure of the support paper, it will remain similar to this proposal. There will

be four overall sections: 1. Introduction, 2. Research Aims, 3. Methodology, and 4. Conclusion. The

Introduction will remain one section, with a more extensive explanations and definitions. Research

Aims will be split into two sections, 2.1 Dystopia and 2.2 Slice-of-Life. Slice-of-Life may also have

sections, such as 2.2.1 Art and Literature and 2.2.2 Cottagecore. The methodology will consist of

three sections: 3.1 Inner Quandaries and Contextualization, 3.2 Object Implementation, and 3.3 The

Creation Process. Finally, the Conclusion, like the Introduction will be one section, providing a small

wrap-up of what was stated in the support paper.




Bibliography



Atwood, Margaret. A Handmaid’s Tale. Everyman’s Library, 2006.

Baldree, Travis. Legends and Lattes. Tor Trade, 2022.

Barker, M., Chaiken, I., Chang, Y., Fortenberry, D., Hockin, S., Littlefield, W., Miller, B.,

Morano, R., Moss, E., Sears, F., Siracusa, F., Tuchman, E., Weber, J., Wilson, D.

(Executive Producers). (present 2016). A Handmaid’s Tale [TV Series]. Daniel Wilson

Productions; Littlefield Company; White Oak Pictures; MGM Television.

Bradbury, Ray. Fahrenheit 451. Reissue edition, Simon & Schuster, 2012.

Chambers, Becky. A Psalm for the Wild-Built. Monk and Robot series, First, Tom Doherty

Associate, 2021.

Collins, Suzanne. The Hunger Games. Reprint edition, Scholastic Press, 2010.

Dunne, Anthony, and Fiona Raby. Speculative Everything. Massachusetts Institute of

Technology, 2013.

Heathcote, Edwin. (2021). “What is cottagecore? ‘Your grandma but, like, hip.’” The Financial Times

Limited. https://www.proquest.com/tr ade-journals/what-is-cottagecore-your-grandmalikehip/

docview/2514321505/se-2?accountid=12063

The Hunger Games. Directed by Gary Ross, Lionsgate, Videocine, 2012.

Huxley, Aldous. A Brave New World. Reprint edition, Harper Perennial Modern Classics, 2006.

Kawaguchi, Toshikazu. Before the Coffee Gets Cold. Translated by Geoffrey Trousselot,

Original edition, Hanover Square Press, 2020.

Kirkman, Robert. The Walking Dead. Image Comics, 2003.

Lowry, Lois. The Giver. Reprint, Media Tie In edition, Clarion Books, 1993.

Maillardet, Henri. Draughtsman-Writer. 1800, https://www.fi.edu/en/historyresources/

automaton. The Franklin Institute Science Museum, Philadelphia,

Pennsylvania, USA.

Mechanical Art & Design Museum. “The History of Automata.” https://themadmuseum.co.

uk/history-of-automata/. Accessed 2 Feb. 2023.

Mecklin, John. “A Time of Unprecedented Danger: It Is 90 Seconds to Midnight.” Bulletin of the

Atomic Scientists, 24 Jan. 2023, https://thebulletin.org/doomsday-clock/current-time/.

Orwell, George. 1984. Signet Classic, 1961.

Plague Inc. Directed by Ndemic Creations, 2012.

Roth, Veronica. Divergent. Reprint edition, Katherine Tegen Books, 2014.

Shusterman, Neal. Unwind. Reprint edition, S&S Books for Young Readers, 2009.

Snow White and the Seven Dwarves. Directed by David Hand et al., Walt Disney Productions, 1938.

“Speculation.” Cambridge Advanced Learner’s Dictionary & Thesaurus, Cambridge University

Press, 20 Apr. 2013, https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/speculation.

The Giver. Directed by Phillip Noyce, 2014.

The Walking Dead. Directed by Frank Darabont, AMC, AMC Networks, Fox, 2022 2010.

The Wizard of Oz. Directed by Vicor Fleming, Leows Cineplex Entertainment, 1939.

Winskowicz, Abby. 2021, March 31. “Cottagecore aesthetic goes viral on social media.” Uloop, Inc.

https://www.proquest.com/wire-feeds/cottagecore-aesthetic-goes-viral-onsocialmedia/

docview/2507297690/se-2?accountid=12063




Schedule



2023 Summer Semester:

• Support Paper Writing

o Continue to research topics of interest to the thesis

§ Speculation (fiction, visual art, future studies, children's speculation in play,

etc.)

§ Automata, doll houses

o Continue to write in the Background and Methodology sections of the support paper

(add 6-8 pages)

o Take notes on the construction process throughout the semester

• Thesis Construction

o Plan out each vignette in overarching sketches as well as begin to sketch out the

details of the diorama portion of the pieces

o Articulate the mechanics of one of the vignettes

o Start gathering supplies



2023 Fall Semester:

• Support Paper Writing

o Take notes on the construction process throughout the semester

o Continue to write in the Background and Methodology sections of the support paper

(add 6-8 pages)

o Have writing center review support paper

o Have supervisor review support paper

• Thesis Construction

o Construct the bases of the vignettes

o Articulate the mechanics for the rest of the vignettes

o Start the base level of construction for the vignettes and their mechanics (basic

structures, printing out the mechanical parts, etc.)



2024 Spring Semester:

• Support Paper Writing

o Formulate the notes of the last two semesters' construction process into a written

form

o Write Introduction section of the support paper

o Take notes on the construction process throughout the semester

o Have writing center review support paper

o Have committee review support paper

• Thesis Construction

o Work on the details of the vignettes (painting, textile elements, etc.)

o Trouble shoot any possible mechanical problems

o If time permits, include musical elements (in the form or music boxes or speakers)



2024 Summer Semester:

• Support Paper Writing

o Formulate the notes of the last semester's construction process into a written form

o Final committee review the support paper

o Final Revisions

• Thesis Construction

o Any last minute touches

• Exhibition at Penny Gallery: May 20th - June 3rd

• Dissertation: TBD (most likely at some point during the span of the exhibition